~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Outstanding speech by Matti Friedman former AP journalist who covered Israel for Associated Press.
He gave this speech at a BICOM dinner in London on January 26, 2015.
Selected excerpts:
- The international press in Israel had become less an observer of the conflict than a player in it. It had moved away from careful explanation and toward a kind of political character assassination
- Israel’s flaws were dissected and magnified, while the flaws of its enemies were purposely erased
- Something toxic is driving this – ” Jews are troublemakers, a negative force in world events, and that if these people, as a collective, could somehow be made to vanish, we would all be better off”.
- When I worked in the AP’s Jerusalem bureau, the Israel story was covered by more AP news staff than China, or India, or all of the fifty-odd countries of sub-Saharan Africa combined. This is representative of the industry as a whole.
- People observing this conflict from afar have been led to believe that Israel faces a simple choice between occupation and peace. That choice is fiction.
- The Palestinian choice, it is said, is between Israeli occupation and an independent democracy. That choice, too, is fiction
- (Partition for the creation of an Islamic Palestinian state) will bring the black-masked soldiers of radical Islam within yards of Israeli homes with mortars, rockets, and tunneling implements. Many thousands will die.
- No international investment or guarantees, no Western-backed government or Western-trained military will be able to keep that from happening, as we have just seen in Iraq.
- The only group of people subject to a systematic boycott at present in the Western world is Jews, appearing now under the convenient euphemism “Israelis.”
- The Jews of the Middle East are outnumbered by the Arabs of the Middle East 60 to 1, and by the world’s Muslims 200 to 1.
- Neo-Nazi rallies at Palestinian universities or in Palestinian cities are not covered — I saw images of such rallies suppressed on more than one occasion.
- Jewish hatred of Arabs is a story. Arab hatred of Jews is not.
- The time has come for everyone to admit that the fashionable disgust for Israel among many in the West is not liberal but is selective, disproportionate, and discriminatory.
Following are the speech highlights compiled by Israpundit.
They are followed by the entire transcript of Mr Friedman's speech.
They are followed by the entire transcript of Mr Friedman's speech.
HIGHLIGHTS
TRUTHS
Blogger's note:
Please keep in mind - as you start reading this speech where Mr Friedman refers to Israeli checkpoints - that we in the West are subjected to security scrutiny that can be just as bad or worse than the one experienced by Arabs at checkpoints.
Ever since 9/11 all air travellers are routinely subjected to extreme indignities by US airport security staff.
Because of Muslim terror threats.
As an example read article and watch video of a disabled toddler in a wheelchair made to wait for special scrutiny by US airport security, oblivious to her cries of fear and confusion.
On top of that they confiscated her beloved plush toy bunny.
She was dreaming of seeing Disney World. Instead, she was subjected to a traumatic experience. Perhaps this was part of US security efforts to appear not to be doing "racial profiling".
Read more and see video: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2281769/Parents-fury-TSA-detains-wheelchair-bound-daughter-3-theyre-trying-fly-Disney-World-family-vacation.html
- I gradually began to be aware of certain malfunctions in the coverage of the Israel story – recurring omissions, recurring inflations, decisions made according to considerations that were not journalistic but political,
- We sought to hint or say outright that Israeli soldiers were war criminals, and every detail supporting that portrayal was to be seized upon.
- Neo-Nazi rallies at Palestinian universities or in Palestinian cities are not — I saw images of such rallies suppressed on more than one occasion. Jewish hatred of Arabs is a story. Arab hatred of Jews is not.
- Our policy, for example, was not to mention the assertion in the Hamas founding charter that Jews were responsible for engineering both world wars and the Russian and French revolutions.
- 100 houses in a West Bank settlement are a story. 100 rockets smuggled into Gaza are not.
- The Hamas military buildup amid and under the civilian population of Gaza is not a story. But Israeli military action responding to that threat – that is a story,
- Israel’s responsibility for the deaths of civilians as a result – that’s a story. Hamas’s responsibility for those deaths is not
- Israel’s flaws were dissected and magnified, while the flaws of its enemies were purposely erased.
- Threats facing Israel were disregarded or even mocked as figments of the Israeli imagination,
- A fictional image of Israel and of its enemies was manufactured, polished, and propagated to devastating effect by inflating certain details, ignoring others, and presenting the result as an accurate picture of reality.
- The international press in Israel had become less an observer of the conflict than a player in it. It had moved away from careful explanation and toward a kind of political character assassination
- Something toxic is driving this – ” Jews are troublemakers, a negative force in world events, and that if these people, as a collective, could somehow be made to vanish, we would all be better off”.
TRUTHS
- The occupation is not the conflict, which of course predates the occupation. It is a symptom of the conflict, a conflict that would remain even if the symptom were somehow solved.
- an end to the occupation will create a power vacuum that will be filled, as all power vacuums in the region have been, not by the forces of democracy and modernity, which in our region range from weak to negligible, but by the powerful and ruthless, by the extremists
- People observing this conflict from afar have been led to believe that Israel faces a simple choice between occupation and peace. That choice is fiction.
- The Palestinian choice, it is said, is between Israeli occupation and an independent democracy. That choice, too, is fiction
- The only group of people subject to a systematic boycott at present in the Western world is Jews, appearing now under the convenient euphemism “Israelis.”
- The only country that has its own “apartheid week” on campuses is the Jewish country.
- No one cares that, “The human costs of the Middle Eastern adventures of America and Britain in this century have been far higher, and far harder to explain, than anything Israel has ever done. They have involved occupations, and the violence they unleashed continues.”
- the fashionable disgust for Israel among many in the West is not liberal but is selective, disproportionate, and discriminatory
- The cult’s priesthood can be found among the activists, NGO experts, and ideological journalists who have turned coverage of this conflict into a catalogue of Jewish moral failings,
- boycotts of Israel, and only of Israel, which are one of the cult’s most important practices, have significant support in the press, including among editors.
- Sympathy for Israel’s predicament is highly unpopular in the relevant social circles, and is something to be avoided by anyone wishing to be invited to the right dinner parties, or to be promoted.
- the events in Gaza this summer were portrayed not as a complicated war but as a massacre of innocents.
- The Jew is the perennial scapegoat for all that is wrong with the world.
- As the journalist Charles Maurras wrote, approvingly, in 1911: “Everything seems impossible, or frighteningly difficult, without the providential arrival of anti-Semitism, through which all things fall into place and are simplified.”
- the global villain, as portrayed in newspapers and on TV, is none other than the Jewish soldier, or the Jewish settler. They are the heirs to the Jewish banker or Jewish commissar of the past.
- The world isn’t fixated on Israel despite everything else going on – but rather because of everything else going on.
His speech is an absolute must-read.
It is long but worth every minute you take to read it.
Blogger's note:
Please keep in mind - as you start reading this speech where Mr Friedman refers to Israeli checkpoints - that we in the West are subjected to security scrutiny that can be just as bad or worse than the one experienced by Arabs at checkpoints.
Ever since 9/11 all air travellers are routinely subjected to extreme indignities by US airport security staff.
Because of Muslim terror threats.
As an example read article and watch video of a disabled toddler in a wheelchair made to wait for special scrutiny by US airport security, oblivious to her cries of fear and confusion.
On top of that they confiscated her beloved plush toy bunny.
She was dreaming of seeing Disney World. Instead, she was subjected to a traumatic experience. Perhaps this was part of US security efforts to appear not to be doing "racial profiling".
Read more and see video: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2281769/Parents-fury-TSA-detains-wheelchair-bound-daughter-3-theyre-trying-fly-Disney-World-family-vacation.html
TRANSCRIPT OF THE ENTIRE SPEECH
by Matti Friedman
One night several years ago, I came out of Bethlehem after a reporting assignment and crossed through the Israeli military checkpoint between that city and its neighbor, Jerusalem, where I live.
Continue reading and see related cartoons and references
Continue reading and see related cartoons and references